Outside in- 10F and shoveling snow proved I needed help. What a blessing these gloves have been! No extra chilly hands as these gloves give me just what I needed. I'd personally hugely recommend the Extremely flex gloves. Kevin They are undoubtedly the best heated socks on the market. https://beckettlscbh.ssnblog.com/31206689/the-basic-principles-of-hottest-heated-jacket